Can Out-of-Pocket Expenses Be Recovered in a Personal Injury Settlement?

Yes. Out-of-pocket expenses can usually be recovered in a New York personal injury settlement. These are costs you paid yourself because of the accident: medical bills, transportation to appointments, prescriptions, home care, and similar expenses. To recover them, they need to be reasonable, necessary, and backed by receipts, bills, or other proof that ties them to your injury.

"Out-of-pocket" just means money that left your own wallet because of the accident and wasn't paid back at the time. These costs are part of what lawyers call economic damages (also known as "special" damages). Those are the concrete, calculable financial losses tied to your injury, as opposed to non-economic damages like pain and suffering. When a case settles, documented out-of-pocket costs are usually the easiest part to recover. You can prove them with paper instead of arguing over a subjective value.

Below, we explain what qualifies as an out-of-pocket expense and how New York's no-fault system affects car accident claims. We also cover an important 2026 change to the "serious injury" threshold that affects pain-and-suffering claims. Then we walk through how to prove your expenses and what to do if an insurer denies them. At The Orlow Firm, we've handled personal injury claims for injured New Yorkers since 1982. Organizing these costs correctly is one of the first things we work through with clients.

Updated July 2026 to reflect New York's motor vehicle tort reform, including the elimination of the 90/180-day serious injury category effective May 26, 2026.

What Counts as an Out-of-Pocket Expense

An out-of-pocket expense is any accident-related cost you paid yourself and were not paid back for. If the expense would not exist "but for" the injury, and it was reasonable and necessary, it generally belongs in your claim.

Common out-of-pocket expenses in a personal injury case include:

• Medical costs your insurance didn't cover: co-pays, deductibles, and balances left after coverage, plus any care you paid for directly
• Prescriptions and medical supplies: medications, crutches, braces, slings, bandages, and similar items
• Transportation to medical care: rideshare, subway and bus fares, taxi trips, parking, tolls, and mileage for driving your own car to appointments
• In-home help: a home health aide, visiting nurse, or paid help with tasks you can no longer do yourself while you recover
• Childcare or household services you had to hire because your injury stopped you from handling them
• Personal property damaged in the accident: eyeglasses, clothing, a phone, or other items broken during the injury event

Transportation deserves special attention in New York City. Many injured people assume a subway swipe or a short rideshare to physical therapy is too small to matter. It isn't. Over weeks or months of appointments, MetroCard fares, rideshares, and parking near a Manhattan specialist add up fast. Every one of those trips is a recoverable cost when you document it and tie it to your treatment.

One distinction matters for accuracy: lost wages are a separate category from out-of-pocket expenses. The two are almost always discussed together in a settlement, but they aren't the same thing. Out-of-pocket costs are money you spent. Lost wages are money you didn't earn because the injury kept you from working. Both are economic damages, both belong in your claim, and both need documentation. They're just calculated differently. It helps to think of them as two buckets rather than one. We come back to lost wages in a section below.

How New York's No-Fault System Affects Recovery

New York is a no-fault state for motor vehicle accidents. If you're hurt in a car accident, your own insurer's Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage pays certain costs first, no matter who caused the crash.

Under New York law, basic PIP (no-fault) coverage provides up to $50,000 per person. It pays for reasonable and necessary medical expenses, part of your lost earnings, and other reasonable expenses tied to the injury. That's according to the New York Department of Financial Services. Every driver in New York must carry this minimum PIP coverage as part of their auto policy, per the DFS minimum insurance requirements.

Some policies include Additional PIP (APIP), which can extend coverage beyond the basic $50,000. This is optional, and not everyone carries it. It's worth checking your policy rather than assuming it applies.

No-fault is powerful, but it has limits. Understanding those limits is where out-of-pocket recovery really matters:

• When PIP is exhausted. Once your $50,000 (or more, with APIP) runs out, extra accident-related costs don't simply disappear. You can pursue them directly against the at-fault driver and that driver's liability insurer through a bodily injury claim.
• When no-fault doesn't apply at all. No-fault and PIP only exist for motor vehicle accidents. If you were hurt in a slip and fall, a premises accident, a dog bite, or a construction incident, there is no PIP layer. Your out-of-pocket costs are pursued from the start as part of a liability claim against the responsible party.

In other words, the no-fault system changes the path your out-of-pocket expenses take in a car accident case. It doesn't take away your right to recover costs that go beyond PIP or fall outside it. For non-vehicle injuries, the liability claim is simply the direct and only route.

The Serious Injury Threshold — What Changed in 2026

In motor vehicle cases, New York uses a "serious injury" threshold. It decides whether an injured person can pursue non-economic damages (pain and suffering) beyond the no-fault system. This threshold changed in a significant way in 2026. It's important to understand what did and did not change.

What the threshold does: In a car accident case, you generally cannot sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering unless your injury clears a legal bar. It has to meet the definition of a "serious injury" under New York Insurance Law § 5102. If your injury doesn't meet that bar, your recovery in a car accident case is generally limited to economic losses within the no-fault system.

What changed on May 26, 2026: As part of New York's motor vehicle tort reform, the "90/180-day" category was removed for actions started on or after that date. Under the old rule, you could meet the threshold by showing a medically-determined injury with a specific effect. It had to stop you from doing substantially all of your usual daily activities for at least 90 of the first 180 days after the accident. That temporary-duration path no longer exists.

The remaining serious injury categories now require objective medical evidence of permanent or significant impairment. They include:

• Death
• Dismemberment
• Significant disfigurement
• A fracture
• Loss of a fetus
• Permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function, or system
• Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member
• Significant limitation of use of a body function or system

The same 2026 reform package also shifted motor vehicle actions from pure to modified comparative negligence. That bars recovery when a claimant is found more than 50% at fault. It also added a fault-then-threshold sequencing rule under Insurance Law § 5104. Those are related changes worth knowing about. The threshold change is the one that most directly affects out-of-pocket recovery.

Here's the practical takeaway, and it's reassuring. This change affects the threshold for pain and suffering. It does not affect your right to recover documented out-of-pocket and economic costs. For someone with a real but recovering injury, non-economic damages may now be harder to pursue in a car accident case. That's true of many soft-tissue or short-recovery cases that used to clear the bar through the 90/180 path. So careful documentation of your out-of-pocket expenses is more important now, not less. For claims that don't meet the new threshold, those economic costs may be the main recovery available.

Proving Your Out-of-Pocket Expenses

The rule of thumb is simple. If you can't document it, you'll have a much harder time recovering it. Insurers don't accept expenses on trust. They want proof that each cost was real, reasonable, necessary, and caused by this injury.

To build a strong record of your out-of-pocket expenses:

• Keep every receipt, bill, invoice, and Explanation of Benefits (EOB). Paper or digital both work, as long as they're legible and dated.
• Organize by category (medical, transportation, home care, and supplies) so the total in each area is clear at a glance.
• Keep a running payment log with the date, the amount, what it was for, and how you paid. A simple spreadsheet is enough.
• Keep a mileage log for any trips you take in your own vehicle to medical appointments, pharmacies, or therapy. Note the date, destination, and round-trip distance.

The reason insurers push back is always the same. Was this cost reasonable, was it necessary, and was it caused by this injury rather than a pre-existing condition or something unrelated? A well-organized file answers all three questions before the adjuster has to ask. Sparse documentation invites disputes. Thorough documentation shuts most of them down.

Lost Wages and Travel Costs Alongside Out-of-Pocket Expenses

Out-of-pocket expenses rarely travel alone. In most settlement demands, they're bundled with lost wages and travel costs into a single picture of your total economic loss.

Lost wages cover income you didn't earn because of the injury. That includes time you missed entirely, hours you had to cut back, and lost bonuses or commissions tied to work you couldn't perform. Documentation is what makes these numbers stick. Pay stubs from before and after the accident help, as does a letter from your employer confirming the missed time and your rate of pay. Tax records help for self-employed or commission-based income. If your injury affects your ability to earn going forward, reduced future earning capacity is a related but separate category. It usually needs expert support to value.

Travel costs are their own line item. In New York City, that means subway and bus fares to and from treatment, plus parking fees near medical offices. It also covers tolls, rideshare charges, and mileage for personal-vehicle trips. Each one looks minor on its own. Across a full course of treatment they can add up to a real sum. That's exactly why the mileage log and saved fare receipts matter.

When a settlement demand goes to the insurer, these three streams are presented together as your documented economic damages: out-of-pocket costs, lost wages, and travel. A clear, categorized total is far more convincing than a vague estimate. It also gives the adjuster far less room to negotiate the number down.

Why Out-of-Pocket Claims Get Disputed or Denied

Even well-founded expense claims run into resistance. Knowing the common reasons helps you head them off:

• Missing or incomplete documentation. This is the single most frequent problem. If there's no receipt, bill, or log entry, the insurer treats the cost as unproven.
• Disputes over "reasonable and necessary." An adjuster may argue a treatment, device, or service wasn't medically required, or that a cheaper option existed.
• Causation disputes. Insurers often claim an expense comes from a pre-existing condition or something unrelated to the accident, rather than the injury at issue.
• Exhausted no-fault limits with no clear next step. In car accident cases, people sometimes stop pursuing costs once PIP runs out. They don't realize those costs may be recoverable directly from the at-fault party.
• Missed deadlines. The statute of limitations is the deadline to file your lawsuit. In New York, that deadline for most personal injury (negligence) claims is three years from the date of the accident under CPLR § 214(5). Different and often much shorter deadlines apply in some situations. Claims against a city or public agency require an early notice of claim. Special rules apply to cases involving minors or wrongful death, per the New York Courts statute of limitations chart. Missing the deadline that applies to you can bar recovery entirely, no matter how well-documented your expenses are.

Most of these disputes trace back to documentation and timing. A complete, organized file addresses the first three. Awareness of the deadlines addresses the last two.

What to Do If Your Expenses Are Denied

A denial is not the end of the road. It usually means the insurer wants more, clearer proof, or that they're testing whether you'll push back. If your out-of-pocket expenses are denied:

1. Read the denial carefully. The letter should state a specific reason: not enough documentation, a "not reasonable and necessary" finding, a causation dispute, or exhausted benefits. The reason tells you what to fix.
2. Reassemble and strengthen your documentation. Gather any missing receipts. Request fully itemized bills from providers so each charge is spelled out instead of lumped together.
3. Follow the formal appeal process. No-fault and liability claims have set procedures for disputing a denial. A clear, documented appeal through the correct channel is often what turns an initial "no" into a payment.
4. Bring in an attorney when the stakes justify it. Some denials call for a lawyer: a large denial, a serious causation dispute, or a case where your no-fault benefits have run out and you're unsure how to pursue the balance. An experienced personal injury lawyer can organize the claim, handle the appeal, and negotiate directly with the insurer.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is considered an out-of-pocket expense in a personal injury case?

It's any accident-related cost you paid yourself and were not paid back for. That includes medical co-pays and deductibles, prescriptions, medical supplies, transportation to appointments, in-home care, hired childcare, and personal property damaged in the accident. The core test: was the cost reasonable, necessary, and caused by the injury?

How do I prove out-of-pocket expenses without receipts?

Receipts are ideal, but not the only proof. Bank and credit card statements, pharmacy printouts, and provider invoices can help. EOBs from your health insurer, employer letters, and a payment or mileage log kept at the time also work. The more independent records point to the same expense, the stronger your claim.

Does New York no-fault insurance cover all my medical bills?

Not necessarily. Basic PIP (no-fault) coverage pays reasonable and necessary medical expenses up to $50,000 per person, along with part of your lost earnings and other reasonable expenses. If your bills exceed that limit, the excess isn't covered by basic no-fault, but it may be recoverable directly from the at-fault driver's liability insurance. Some drivers carry Additional PIP that raises the limit.

What happens when my no-fault (PIP) benefits run out?

Your accident-related costs don't disappear. Once PIP is exhausted, additional documented expenses can be pursued through a bodily injury claim against the at-fault driver and that driver's liability insurer. This is one of the most common points where injured people stop too early. Costs beyond the no-fault limit are often still recoverable with the right claim.

Can I still sue for pain and suffering if my injury isn't permanent?

It's harder than it used to be. In motor vehicle cases, pain and suffering requires meeting New York's serious injury threshold. The 90/180-day category, which let some temporary injuries qualify, was removed effective May 26, 2026. The remaining categories generally require a fracture or a permanent, significant impairment, though your out-of-pocket costs stay recoverable either way.

How long do I have to file a personal injury lawsuit in New York?

For most personal injury claims based on negligence, the deadline is three years from the date of the accident under CPLR § 214(5). Important exceptions exist: claims against a city or public agency require a notice of claim filed much sooner, and different rules apply to cases involving minors and wrongful death. Confirm the deadline that applies to you early.

Sources & Official Resources

New York Laws Cited

1. CPLR § 214 — Statute of Limitations (Personal Injury)
2. Insurance Law § 5102 — Definitions (Serious Injury Threshold)
3. Insurance Law § 5104 — Sequencing of Fault and Threshold Determinations

Insurance & Regulatory Sources 4. NY Department of Financial Services — No-Fault Auto Insurance FAQs 5. NY Department of Financial Services — Minimum Auto Insurance Requirements

Helpful Resources 6. New York Courts — Statute of Limitations Chart

Contact The Orlow Firm

If your out-of-pocket costs after an accident have been denied, delayed, or lowballed, understanding your options is an important first step. The same is true if you're unsure how the 2026 serious injury threshold changes affect your case. The Orlow Firm has helped injured New Yorkers organize their claims and negotiate fair settlements throughout Queens and New York City since 1982.

Call (646) 647-3398 for a free consultation. We work on contingency, so you pay nothing unless we win. We have four NYC office locations. Our main office is in Queens, with Manhattan, Brooklyn, and the Bronx by appointment. And we can come to you if you can't come to us.

Se Habla Español

This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Every case is different. Contact an attorney to discuss your specific situation.