In the span of a few days in early 2011, two bus accidents - one of which involved a bus traveling from a casino in Connecticut to New York City - put the spotlight back on the issue of bus safety. In total, 17 people were killed in the two accidents - 15 in the New York City bus crash alone. In reaction to these recent crashes and others, there are currently two proposals to increase bus safety before Congress. However, there are already a number of rules and regulations on the books, with the rules regulating drivers' hours-of-service being some of the most important.

Hours-of-Service Regulations

In an effort to keep all passengers and others on the road safe, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) regulates the number of hours that a bus driver is allowed to remain behind the wheel. There are three basic kinds of hours-of-service regulations:

On-Duty Limit - after bus drivers are on duty for 15 hours, they are not allowed to drive until eight consecutive hours of off-duty time are taken; however, in an absurd loophole, a driver may continue to conduct non-driving work (like paperwork or vehicle maintenance) after the 15 hours has run.
Driving Limit - the FMCSA only allows bus drivers a total of 10 hours of driving time, driven consecutively or broken up, after eight consecutive hours off duty. Once drivers use all of their drive time, they must be off duty for eight consecutive hours before driving again.
Weekly Limit - called the "60/70 rule," bus drivers are only allowed to drive a certain number of hours in a given (rolling) week, either 60 hours in a seven-day week or 70 hours in an eight-day week.

In December of 2010, the FMCSA proposed to amend the hours-of-service rules for commercial motor vehicle drivers. The proposed rules were aimed at improving safety by further limiting driver hours behind the wheel and on duty.

Motorcoach Enhanced Safety Act

Introduced by Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH) and Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-TX), the Motorcoach Enhanced Safety Act (MESA) would call for:

Seat belts to be installed in all new buses
Seat belts to be retrofitted into all older buses
Passenger ejection protection by installing stronger seats and windows
Bus roofs that are crush resistant
More stringent inspection requirements
Tracking technology similar to the "black box" technology used in airplanes

As is, the American Bus Association chose not to endorse this Act, choosing instead to endorse the Bus Uniform Standards and Enhanced Safety (BUSES) Act of 2011. The American Bus Association - according to information provided by Philly.com - claims that implementing the MESA would cost upwards of $80,000 per bus, according to Philly.com. They argue that the hefty cost associated with compliance would surely result in increased fares that would have a disproportionately negative impact on smaller carrier companies. While the bus industry claims that the costs of this Act would be too high, Philly.com reports that Joan Claybrook, a former administrator of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and currently with Advocates for Highway & Auto Safety (a safety advocacy organization), claims that even a 10 cent raise in fares would be all it takes to cover the increased costs of this Act. If Ms. Claybrook is right, 10 cents is a small price to pay for safety.

The BUSES Act of 2011

Endorsed by the American Bus Association, the Bus Uniform Standards and Enhanced Safety (BUSES) Act of 2011 takes a different approach to bus safety than the MESA. It proposes that - after a period of research and testing - the NHTSA should enact uniform safety rules for the bus industry that would improve safety through:

Installing seat belts
Strengthening roofs and windows
Enhancing emergency egress
Improving fire protection standards
Establishing minimum standards for all drivers seeking a commercial driver's license (CDL) with a passenger endorsement

After the safety rules are set forth, the Act would allow up to an 18-year timeframe for retrofitting older buses. To help offset increased costs associated with improving safety, the Act would also provide grants and tax credits to bus companies. Both proposed Acts seek to improve passenger safety, albeit in somewhat different ways; however, one safety aspect that both have in common is seat belts. According the NHTSA, seat belts on buses reduce the risk of death by an astounding 77 percent during a rollover crash.

Potentially Liable Parties

The bus industry has made it known that, since new safety rules cost money, they favor the least restrictive safety rules. Whether or not the safety measures are implemented, though, bus accidents happen. When bus crashes occur, several different parties may be responsible, including:

The bus driver
The bus company
The bus manufacturer
The manufacturer of the bus' components, including the windows, seats or tires
Other drivers, especially those engaging in drunk driving or distracted driving
Designers or builders of the roads
Municipalities responsible for maintaining roadways on which buses travel

If you have been injured while traveling on a bus, speak with an experienced personal injury attorney. A New York lawyer can help you hold accountable the parties that are responsible for your injuries, allowing you to recover compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. If a loved one has been fatally wounded in a bus accident, an attorney can help you file a wrongful death lawsuit that seeks compensation for medical bills, funeral expenses, loss of consortium and lost future earnings.

Sources

Motor Vehicle Accidents

Brianna's Law

What is Brianna's Law? Quick Answer: Brianna’s Law in New York requires all motorboat operators to complete a state-approved boating safety course. By January 1, 2025, everyone operating a motorized...

Motor Vehicle Accidents

What are the Helmet Requirements in New York?

What are the Helmet Requirements in New York? Quick Answer: In New York, all motorcyclists and their passengers must wear a Department of Transportation (DOT) approved helmet. Children under 14...

Workers Compensation

What Is a Workers’ Compensation Lien and How Does It Affect a Personal Injury Settlement?

What Is a Workers’ Compensation Lien in New York? Quick Answer: In New York, a workers' compensation lien is a legal claim that a workers' compensation insurer or employer has on the proceeds of a...

Police Misconduct

What Are Pattern or Practice Claims in Civil Rights Cases Against Police Departments?

What Is a Pattern or Practice Claim in NYC Civil Rights Cases? Quick Answer: A pattern or practice claim, also referred to as a systemic discrimination claim, asserts that an employer has...

The Orlow Firm’s Accolades

Founded in 1982, The Orlow Firm has earned many top-level honors for its excellence, compassion, and legal excellence. These recognitions reflect our unwavering commitment to achieving justice, delivering results, and providing compassionate, personalized representation to injury victims in Queens and throughout New York City.