Skip to main content

Case Study: NYC Staircase Trip and Fall

Call Now to Request a Free Consultation (646) 647-3398

The Following People Contributed to This Page

Loyda Gomez
Written byLoyda GomezParalegal & Office ManagerB.A.Sc., Political Science & Government, John Jay College of Criminal Justice (CUNY), 22+ years at The Orlow Firm, Bilingual: English and Spanish

Updated: March 11, 2026 · 3 min read

Video
Service jobs are noble livelihoods, as these workers directly help other individuals. However, there are circumstances in which service workers can be injured on the job because of improperly maintained amenities. These amenities fall under the jurisdiction of the owner of the property. Thus, personal injuries to workers — or to anyone — visiting the property should be the responsibility of the property owners. In this particular case, our client was working as a home health aide. Unfortunately, she tripped and fell on the job as a result of stepping on a defective step in a staircase. The client sustained injuries that rendered her unable to work for a long time as she required surgery. The damages were severe — our client suffered a fractured ankle requiring surgery with metal implants to ensure proper healing. Our firm pursued a claim of negligence against the building owner, as it appeared the staircase had not been properly maintained. It was revealed that the building managers had failed to address the defective condition of the staircase despite having constructive notice of its disrepair. Under New York premises liability law, property owners have a duty to maintain their premises in a reasonably safe condition. When a hazardous condition such as a defective staircase causes injury, and the owner knew or should have known about the dangerous condition, they may be held liable for resulting damages. After negotiations between our firm and the building's representatives, we secured a $240,000 settlement for our client, which provided payment for her medical treatment and other reasonable compensation. Should you find yourself in a situation like this, it is helpful to remember that it is the responsibility of the property owner to ensure that the place where someone is working or visiting is safe for use. Negligence on the part of the property owner may require them to pay compensation for damages. Our experienced attorneys at The Orlow Firm strive to ensure our clients receive the best treatment and compensation possible in their cases. We also ensure that our clients are kept up to date on their cases and the possible modes of resolution available to them depending on the situation. If you have been injured due to a dangerous property condition, you can contact The Orlow Firm. We offer free consultations with one of our experienced attorneys and can help with premises liability and personal injury cases.

Sources

The Following People Contributed to This Page

Loyda Gomez
Written byParalegal & Office ManagerB.A.Sc., Political Science & Government, John Jay College of Criminal Justice (CUNY), 22+ years at The Orlow Firm, Bilingual: English and Spanish

Related Articles

Case Studies

Case Study: NYC Sidewalk Slip and Fall

Did you know there are actually cases where the defendant is an entire city? These cases happen when certain situations point towards a city as the one responsible for the damages that happen to the...

Read More
Case Studies

Case Study: NYC Ceiling Falls Through

People who live in apartments will understand the predicament that are amenities that these apartment units provide. This is why the local super is there to make sure little things such as leaks and...

Read More
Case Studies

Case Study: NYC Child Injured by Door

Children are very precious gifts to the world, which is why certain cases like our client here tend to be very sensitive subjects. When it comes to amenities like doors and other functional spaces in...

Read More

The Orlow Firm’s Results

Notable settlements and verdicts for our clients

$5,000,000

Infant Lead Poisoning - Foster Home

Infant placed in foster home with lead paint developed extremely elevated blood lead levels causing neurological problems.

Lead Poisoning
1 of 14

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Our Reviews on Google

The Orlow Firm’s Reputation On Google

The Orlow Firm is rated 4.9/5 across all of our Google reviews (as of March 2026). Below is a small sample of what people are saying about the firm and the compassionate advocacy we provided for them.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Since I have my accident Brain Orlow and his team Been helping me every step with case They. Are concerned about client Make sure they have good access to doctors appointments And financial support For me i will hire this firm again

Rumdy Lazos

My experience from beginning to the end regarding my injury was a smooth transition. Both Adam and Brian guided me accordingly with the least amount of stress possible. Whenever I needed to speak to either of them, they were always available. The information being relayed to me by the other party was always straight forward with no uncertainties. They were honest with my settlement and what was expected. I highly recommend this practice. Everyone in the practice has always been professional and courteous. If I were to ever be in a situation again when I need to seek legal counsel for an injury I will certainly be contacting them again. Many thanks to the Orlow Firm.

Krystle Rivera

There is no word to describe how happy I’am for choosing Orlow firm to defend me. From the moment I contacted the firm , I know was in good hand. I’am very satisfying with the outcome in my case. If want to win your case without fighting so hard, please contact Orlow firm.

Haoua Guira-Ouedraogo

I’m very thankful because of the Orlow firm won my case , trustable , every time I had a question they would respond. Thank you lawyer Bryan for helping me with my case.

Liz Pavia

From the beginning, they showed genuine concern and work with me. They answered all my questions and addressed my worries. They were always working to get me a decent settlement. Brian, Adam and Tom are the best. I want to thank them and their team for all their help. To them it’s not business because they really showed they care.

Mirlyne Oriental

My experience with the Orlow firm was phenomenal. They were very knowledgeable about my situation very caring very informative I was very comfortable with them because kept me informed every step of the way. They were very respectable non-bias of my feelings or my pain. The Orlow firm commanded excellence from the receptionist to all the office staff they never quit on me they stuck it out to the very end and I appreciated that. I thank God for this firm.

PHYLLIS HAIRSTON

Memberships & Accolades

The Orlow Firm’s Accolades

Founded in 1982, The Orlow Firm has earned many top-level honors for its excellence, compassion, and legal excellence. These recognitions reflect our unwavering commitment to achieving justice, delivering results, and providing compassionate, personalized representation to injury victims in Queens and throughout New York City.

Lawyers.com
Super Lawyers
Justia
Martindale-Hubbell AV Rated

Our Locations

We offer free initial consultations and operate four offices across New York City for your convenience. We can go to you if you cannot come to us.

Queens Office (Main)

71-18 Main Street
Queens, NY 11367 Map

(646) 647-3398

Fax: 718-544-6485

Manhattan Office

(By appointment only)

405 Lexington Ave, 26th Floor
New York, NY 10174 Map

(646) 647-3398

Fax: 718-544-6485

Brooklyn Office

(By appointment only)

32 Court Street
Brooklyn, NY 11201 Map

(646) 647-3398

Fax: 718-544-6485

Bronx Office

(By appointment only)

903 Sheridan Avenue, 2nd Floor
Bronx, NY 10453 Map

(646) 647-3398

Fax: 718-544-6485

Request a Free Consultation

Contact Us Today

Attorney Advertising Disclaimer
Notice: The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The Orlow Firm works on a contingent fee basis. A contingent basis means that our attorneys do not charge by consultation but will take a percentage on the amount recovered. This amount is usually one third of the net recovery after disbursement. This means that the cost of hiring The Orlow Firm varies based on the amount recovered.

© 2026 by The Orlow Firm. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy. Terms & Conditions. Sitemap.